I read an interesting article this weekend by Lisa Bodel for Forbes.

The article considers alternatives to the 'outdated' performance review process.

1.  Check Ins - Informal undocumented conversations about performance over the course of a year.  By coaching in real time check ins enable managers to identify and resolve performance issues in a timely manner.

2.  Quarterly Performance Goals - Rather than set goals for the year, quarterly goals have been proven to be effective and a more accurate reflection of the employees overall performance.

3.  Apps - Instead of performance scores or rankings an app to help employees, managers anf team members share feedback for continuous imporvement.

4.  Rewards Training for Managers - Adobe uses a training program to show managers how to make decisions with a varierty of different employee scenarios.

I have added the link to the full article below :-

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lisabodell/2018/04/27/why-performance-reviews-are-irrelevant-today/#250bb7814b63

When working for a previous employer, we moved to a system where you had check ins over the course of the year, with more detailed conversations on a quarterly basis. At least four conversations a year needed to be documented. Objectives/Priorities were reviewed regular and could be updated and change in line with business needs.  I found this a very effective way of managing performance.  

What are your thoughts?

Does your organisation adopt any of these alternative methods? If so have they proved to be effective?

Karen :)

 

You need to be a member of DPG Community to add comments!

Join DPG Community

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Hi Karen

    Thanks for sharing.  I think that it is contextual and depends on the type of organisation.  Increasingly today organisations need to be nimble and change happens constantly,  So as you say how can an annual performance review drive business performance.

    Here is a link to an article from the Harvard Business Review that I often refer to in workshops when we discuss approaches to performance reviews, and how many organisations are now switching these for the types of things you have outlined above.

    Again contextual as for Deloittes they caluclated that performance reviews were costing a staggering amount of money to undetake, I think £200 million.

    https://hbr.org/2015/04/reinventing-performance-management

    Also some additional info on Amazon, Goole and Netflix again all businesses that need to respond quickly to changes in their operating environments.

    https://www.etsplc.com/replacing-performance-ratings-how-amazon-del...

    How is it approached in other people's organisations I wonder?

     

    Sarah

    Reinventing Performance Management
    How one company is rethinking peer feedback and the annual review, and trying to design a system to fuel improvement
This reply was deleted.

CIPD Branch Events

Did you know your local CIPD branch will put on relevant events that are free to CIPD members.

Take a look for your local branch here and what events are happening. Remember attending these events are great CPD evidence.

CIPD Branch Event Search

What's Happening?

Bryony Ellis and Syed Zain Ul Abidien are now connected
1 hour ago
Louise Kirwan commented on Sean Timbrell's blog post HR books and materials
1 hour ago
Heather Neep and Suki Gill are now connected
1 hour ago
Julie Forder posted a status
anyone having issues with the courses? I'm trying to do HRF but it's getting stuck and spooling on the CPD disclaimer page. So frustrating! today is my first day back studying since march...
3 hours ago
Lois Anderson and Ashleigh Norris-Seal are now connected
19 hours ago
Karen Cottam liked Gary Norris's blog post CPD with G: curration for the people occupation 25/09/20
23 hours ago
Gary Norris posted a blog post
23 hours ago
Freda Chiu, Lara Valdur Eha and Chris Roots joined DPG Community
yesterday
More…